Is Lucid Dreaming Real? What Science Says
Punti chiave
- Lucid dreaming is real: a lucid dream is a dream in which you know you're dreaming, and sleep labs have verified it since the early 1980s by having sleepers signal with their eyes from inside REM sleep.
- About 55% of people have had at least one lucid dream, and about 23% have one or more a month, according to a meta-analysis of 50 years of research.
- In a 2021 study run by four labs, lucid dreamers answered 29 of 158 questions correctly from inside REM sleep, against 1 correct answer in 379 attempts with sleepers who weren't lucid.
- When people tracked a moving object in a lucid dream, their real eyes moved smoothly, the way they do when watching something awake, and not in the jerky way they move when imagining it.
- In one week of practising induction techniques, 355 people went from a lucid dream on 5% of mornings to 16%, whether or not they had lucid dreamed before.
Lucid dreaming sounds like something written for a film: you're asleep, you know you're asleep, and sometimes you can decide what happens next. So it's fair to wonder whether it's real, or whether the people who describe it were half awake, imagining things or just telling a good story. Lucid dreaming is real, and unlike most claims about dreams, it has been proven from outside the dreamer's head. Here's how we know, how to tell if you've had one, and whether you can learn it.
Is lucid dreaming real?#
Yes, lucid dreaming is real, and sleep researchers have been recording it in the lab for more than 40 years. A lucid dream is a dream in which you know you're dreaming while it's still going on.[1] The dream keeps running (the street, the people, the strange logic), but part of you knows none of it is real. Some lucid dreamers use that moment to fly or to change the scene, and others simply look around. If you want the full picture of what the experience is like, what lucid dreams are covers it.
Lucid dreams are also far more common than their reputation, given how exotic they sound. When researchers pooled 50 years of surveys, about 55% of people said they'd had at least one lucid dream, and about 23% had one or more a month.[2] So if you've ever had the odd feeling, in the middle of a dream, that you were dreaming, you're in the majority. And if you've never had it, you're far from alone (the lucid dreaming FAQ has more on who gets them and how often).
Why scientists doubted lucid dreams for so long#
People have described lucid dreams for a very long time. In the fourth century BCE, Aristotle wrote that "often when one is asleep, there is something in consciousness which declares that what then presents itself is but a dream". The Dutch psychiatrist Frederik van Eeden gave the experience its name in 1913. But for most of that time, the only evidence was what dreamers said after they woke up, and some scientists and philosophers doubted it could happen at all.
The scientists had a narrower worry, and a fair one. A dream report is told in the morning, from memory, by someone who is now awake. Some researchers wondered whether so-called lucid dreams were really brief waking hallucinations between bouts of sleep.[3] We all wake for a few seconds here and there during the night, usually without remembering it. It would be easy to blend one of those awake moments with the dream around it, and remember the whole thing as a dream you were aware of. To settle it, someone had to show that the dreamer knew they were dreaming while the machines said they were asleep.
How scientists proved lucid dreaming is real#
The way in came from a quirk of REM sleep, the stage of the night when most vivid dreams happen. During REM our brains switch off almost every muscle in the body, so we don't act out our dreams (a good thing, if you've ever dreamed you were running). But the eyes still move, and when you look left in a dream, your real eyes tend to look left too, which researchers began to use in the late 1970s. Before going to sleep, lucid dreamers agreed on a signal: as soon as they realized they were dreaming, they would look all the way left, then all the way right, twice.
At Stanford, five lucid dreamers did exactly that, signalling that they knew they were dreaming while their recordings showed unmistakable REM sleep, and then carrying on with the dream.[4] The same left-right signal is still the standard way to verify a lucid dream in the lab.
A person who's awake can't fake it, because the sleep recording shows they're asleep, and a person who isn't lucid has no reason to make it. It seems like a small trick, two glances left and right, but it turned a private experience that nobody could check into something a stranger could read off a screen in the next room.
Talking to someone in a dream#
In 2021, four labs in the US, Germany, France and the Netherlands went a step further and asked dreamers questions. They spoke simple maths problems or flashed them as lights, and the dreamers answered from inside their dreams by moving their eyes a set number of times.[5] In one lab the answers were yes or no, given by tensing the muscle we smile with or the one we frown with. Lucid dreamers got 29 of their 158 questions right. When the teams tried the same thing with sleepers who weren't lucid, as a check that the answers weren't just random twitches of a sleeping face, they got one correct answer in 379 attempts.
Questions answered correctly during REM sleep
- Lucid dreamers: 18%
- Sleepers who weren't lucid: 0.3%
Source: Konkoly et al., 2021[5]. 36 sleepers in four labs, 537 questions.
The questions didn't always arrive the way they were sent. A Dutch participant who was sitting in a car in the dream said the maths problems "felt like a sort of radio in the car". A German dreamer heard "4 plus 0" when the lights had spelled out "4 minus 0" (he answered 4, which happened to be right for both).
The most striking report came from a 20-year-old Frenchman with narcolepsy, a sleep disorder that drops you into REM sleep within minutes of nodding off. He said he had about four lucid dreams a day. He was asked whether he liked chocolate and whether he studied biology, and he answered with his face muscles from a party in his dream.
I heard your voice as if you were a God. Your voice was coming from the outside, just like a narrator of a movie.
Brain recordings tell the same story as the eye signals. In another study, lucid dreamers clenched their left and right fists in the dream while their brain activity was recorded, marking each set with the eye signal. The part of the brain that moves the hands became active as they clenched, at about half the strength of a real fist clench while awake.[6] Only two of the six volunteers managed the task in a lucid dream (which says a lot about how hard these studies are to run). But it was the first time anyone had watched a specific piece of a dream on a brain scan.
Is a lucid dream just your imagination?#
This is the doubt people raise most, often right after their first one. Couldn't you just be imagining it, half awake, the way you can picture a beach right now with your eyes open? And how would you ever tell the difference? One clever experiment answers it with your eyes. When you follow a moving object while awake, your eyes glide smoothly after it. When you only imagine the object moving, they can't do that, and they jump along in small jerks. Skilled lucid dreamers held out a thumb in the dream, moved it slowly in a circle or a line and followed the thumbnail with their gaze. Their real eyes moved smoothly, just as when they followed their thumb awake.[7]
In other words, seeing something in a lucid dream is closer to seeing than to imagining, at least for your eyes. That fits what lucid dreamers say, which is that the dream often feels as solid as the room you're reading this in. In the brain, a lucid dream looks like ordinary REM sleep with some extra activity, mostly at the front, in areas we use to reflect on our own thoughts. Most of these studies are small (a handful of skilled dreamers, sometimes one), so the details may well change, but none of them leaves room for "it's all made up".
The neuroscience gets its own post, the neuroscience behind lucid dreams, and the wider body of lab work is in the science of lucid dreaming. For your own nights, the question is usually simpler.
How do you know if you had a lucid dream?#
You had a lucid dream if, at some point inside it, you knew you were dreaming. That's the whole definition. You don't need to have controlled anything, flown anywhere or stayed lucid for long.
A dream that was only very vivid, or one where you woke up and then realized it had been a dream, doesn't count, because the knowing has to happen during the dream. Plenty of people search for an answer after exactly that kind of night, and it was most likely an ordinary dream with a strong ending.
It often starts with one small thing that doesn't fit. Christopher Mazurek had his first lucid dream as a student at Northwestern University. He was in a campus dining hall in the middle of winter, in the dream, when he noticed he wasn't wearing his favourite coat. The dream fell apart seconds later and he woke up, but he's had many since, and he has taken part in several lucid dream studies.
I realized that, OK, if I don't have the coat, I must be dreaming.
Lucidity also comes in degrees. You can half-suspect you're dreaming, lose the thought, and find it again, and the neuroscientist Martin Dresler puts it plainly: "Lucid dreaming is not a strict all-or-nothing phenomenon." So if you're asking whether a hazy moment of "wait, is this a dream?" counted, the honest answer is that it was the start of one. And watch out for the opposite case, a false awakening, where you dream that you've woken up and your morning routine is part of the dream.
Can everyone lucid dream?#
Nobody has shown that literally everyone can, but most people can learn to have more lucid dreams than they do now, and that includes people who have never had one. Only about 1% of people say they lucid dream several times a week, so if it doesn't come naturally to you, you're the norm, not the exception. Better news comes from a study that put the techniques themselves to the test. Over two weeks, 355 people kept a log of their dreams. They spent the first week as usual and the second practising one of several methods, such as setting the intention to notice you're dreaming before going back to sleep.
Mornings with a lucid dream
- A normal week: 5%
- A week of practice: 16%
Source: Adventure-Heart, 2020[8]. 355 people, one week each.
The share of mornings with a lucid dream tripled in a single week, and the techniques worked whether or not people had lucid dreamed before.[8] Two things predicted who succeeded. The first was how well people remembered their dreams in general, which makes sense, because a lucid dream you forget by breakfast doesn't count. The second was falling back asleep within 10 minutes of doing the technique. The extra lucid dreams didn't hurt sleep quality either, which may be the most useful thing to know if you've read that lucid dreaming is dangerous.
Let's be honest, though, 16% of mornings is still most mornings without one. Lucid dreaming is closer to a skill than a switch, and some nights nothing happens however well you prepare. If you want to start, how to lucid dream walks through the methods from the beginning, and the most popular lucid dream techniques compares them. Oniri's lucid dreaming app keeps your dream journal and your reality checks in one place, so you build the dream recall the study found matters.
The cheapest proof that lucid dreaming is real is the one you can run on yourself. Tonight, before you fall asleep, tell yourself that the next time something odd happens, you'll ask yourself if you're dreaming. If you want to try harder than that, how to have a lucid dream tonight has a plan for the next few hours. And if one night the answer is yes, even for a few seconds, you won't need a sleep lab to tell you it was real.
Domande frequenti
Are vivid dreams and lucid dreams the same?
No. A vivid dream is one that feels detailed and intense, while a lucid dream is one in which you knew you were dreaming at the time. You can have a very vivid dream without ever realizing it was a dream, and a lucid dream can be hazy. Lucid dreams are often described as brighter than ordinary ones, but the test is the awareness, not the detail.
Do lucid dreams happen in REM sleep?
Yes, the lucid dreams verified in sleep labs happen in REM sleep, the stage of the night when most vivid dreams happen. The first lab studies, in the late 1970s and early 1980s, established that lucid dreams take place there. It's also why the eye signals work: REM sleep switches off almost every muscle in your body, but your eyes still follow what you look at in the dream.
Is lucid dreaming every night normal?
It's rare, but it isn't a sign that something is wrong. Only about 1% of people say they lucid dream several times a week. People with narcolepsy often have lucid dreams very frequently, and one patient in a lab study averaged four a day. If your frequent lucid dreams come with heavy sleepiness during the day or sudden sleep attacks, mention it to a doctor, since those are the main signs of narcolepsy.
Can you control a lucid dream?
Sometimes. Knowing you're dreaming and controlling the dream are two different things, and research suggests deliberate control is possible in about a third of lucid dreams. You might decide to fly or change where you are while the rest of the dream carries on by itself. Experienced lucid dreamers say control gets easier with practice, and the jolt of realizing you're dreaming can be enough to wake you up.
Who discovered lucid dreaming?
Nobody discovered it in one go. Aristotle described knowing you're dreaming in the fourth century BCE, and the Dutch psychiatrist Frederik van Eeden coined the term lucid dream in 1913. The scientific proof came in the late 1970s and early 1980s, when Keith Hearne and then Stephen LaBerge's team at Stanford recorded agreed eye signals from sleepers who were lucid in REM sleep.
Fonti e riferimenti
Questo articolo si basa su ricerche pubblicate, studi sottoposti a revisione paritaria e libri di riferimento. Dai un'occhiata alle fonti qui sotto per approfondire.
[1]The cognitive neuroscience of lucid dreaming
Baird, B., Mota-Rolim, S. A., & Dresler, M. · 2019
Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 100
[2]Lucid dreaming incidence: a quality effects meta-analysis of 50 years of research
Saunders, D. T., Roe, C. A., Smith, G., & Clegg, H. · 2016
Consciousness and Cognition, 43
[3]Here's what lucid dreamers might tell us about our sleeping minds
Temming, M. · 2023
Science News
[4]Lucid dreaming verified by volitional communication during REM sleep
LaBerge, S. P., Nagel, L. E., Dement, W. C., & Zarcone, V. P. · 1981
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 52(3)
[5]Real-time dialogue between experimenters and dreamers during REM sleep
Konkoly, K. R., Appel, K., Chabani, E., et al. · 2021
Current Biology, 31(7)
[6]Dreamed movement elicits activation in the sensorimotor cortex
Dresler, M., Koch, S. P., Wehrle, R., et al. · 2011
Current Biology, 21(21)
[7]Smooth tracking of visual targets distinguishes lucid REM sleep dreaming and waking perception from imagination
LaBerge, S., Baird, B., & Zimbardo, P. G. · 2018
Nature Communications, 9
[8]Findings from the International Lucid Dream Induction Study
Adventure-Heart, D. J. · 2020
Frontiers in Psychology, 11

Scritto da
Founder of Oniri
Jean-Baptiste founded Oniri and researches dreams, lucid dreams, creativity, and AI. He collaborates with the Sleep and Cognition Neuroimaging Laboratory in Geneva and is invested in different studies about lucid dreams and the intersection of dreams and AI, including a paper in the Journal of Sleep Research on cathartic dreams.
Condividi questo articolo




















