Is Lucid Dreaming Dangerous? The Real Risks
자각몽글 Jean-Baptiste Beau업데이트됨 November 11, 202611 분 읽기

Is Lucid Dreaming Dangerous? The Real Risks

핵심 요약

  • Lucid dreaming is safe for most people: in a survey of 489 people, nearly all of them lucid dreamers, those who had lucid dreams more often did not sleep worse, and only about 10% of their lucid dreams were unpleasant.
  • The main risk of lucid dreaming comes from induction methods such as Wake Back to Bed, which have you stay awake for 30 minutes to two hours in the middle of the night and so cut into your sleep.
  • Sleep paralysis was the most common complaint in a study of 400 posts on Reddit's lucid dreaming forum, ahead of confusing dreams with waking life, lucid nightmares and poor sleep.
  • People living with psychosis, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder or strong dissociation should talk to a doctor before trying to induce lucid dreams, because the techniques deliberately blur the line between dreaming and waking.
  • A lucid dream cannot trap you or kill you, because it takes place in ordinary REM sleep, which ends on its own several times every night.

About half of us have had at least one lucid dream, a dream in which you know you're dreaming, but only about one person in ten has them a couple of times a month or more.[1] That gap is why so many people try to train for them, with alarms in the night, reality checks during the day and sometimes supplements or gadgets. So is lucid dreaming dangerous? The dream itself isn't, for nearly everyone. The risks sit in some of the methods people use to have more of them, and in a small group of people who are better off not trying. Here's what can go wrong, how often it happens and how to keep it safe.

Is lucid dreaming dangerous?#

No, for most people lucid dreaming isn't dangerous, because a lucid dream happens in REM sleep, the stage most of our vivid dreams come from, which we all go through four or five times a night. The only difference is that the parts of your brain that let you reflect on your own thoughts come back online, so you notice that you're dreaming. Your body stays asleep and the dream ends when the REM period does, the way it would on any other night.

The best data on the question comes from a survey of 489 people, nearly all of them lucid dreamers. Those who had lucid dreams more often didn't sleep worse and weren't more prone to dissociation (the feeling of being detached from yourself or from the world around you). They reported better mental well-being, if anything, and most of them couldn't name a single bad consequence of their lucid dreams. Only about 10% of their lucid dreams were unpleasant.[2] It's an online survey of people who chose to answer, and it shows correlations, so it can't prove that lucid dreaming does no harm. But it's still the closest anyone has come to measuring the side effects directly.

The psychologist who ran it, Tadas Stumbrys, put the result plainly when he talked to PsyPost about it.[3]

So while lucid dreaming itself appears to be safe, putting too much effort into achieving it may not be that good idea.

Tadas Stumbrys[3] Psychologist, Vilnius University

That "too much effort" is where the real problems start, and the people who live with them are easy to find, because they post about it.

What can go wrong in a lucid dream#

If you've read a lucid dreaming forum, you've seen the worries pile up, from frozen bodies to nights of waking up over and over, along with the questions about whether any of it is normal. A team at Northwestern University went through 400 posts on Reddit's lucid dreaming community and sorted every good and bad experience in them. About a quarter of the posts described something good and about a quarter something bad, which is a fairer picture than either the enthusiasts or the warnings suggest.[4]

What lucid dreamers post about

Number of posts that mention each experience

Good experiences

  • Better, more vivid dreams: 69
  • A good mood the next day: 29
  • Ending a nightmare: 17

Bad experiences

  • Sleep paralysis: 49
  • Mixing up dreams and waking life: 26
  • Lucid nightmares: 25
  • Poor sleep: 24
  • Lucid dreams they couldn't stop: 7

Source: Mallett et al., 2022[4]. 400 posts on Reddit's lucid dreaming forum, 2019.

Sleep paralysis tops the list, and it gets its own section below. Next comes confusion between dreaming and waking, which was mostly false awakenings, dreams in which you wake up, get dressed and start your morning, and then wake up for real. A long chain of them can leave you doing reality checks for a while after you get up, just to be sure you're awake. It's unsettling, but it always ends, and the fear of being stuck in one is covered in can you get stuck in a lucid dream (you can't).

Lucid nightmares are the experience people fear most once they've had one. You know you're dreaming, you try to change the dream, and nothing works, or it gets worse. The study found one clear pattern behind them. Posts where the dreamer could steer the dream were far more likely to be positive, and the bad ones were mostly lucidity with no control at all. The way out is the one some of those posters used to end ordinary nightmares, which is to stop fighting the dream and wake yourself up, by trying to open your real eyes or telling yourself to wake. If nightmares are the reason you started, how to have fewer nightmares covers the method sleep doctors use.

Poor sleep and lucid dreams you can't switch off come last. They mostly came from natural lucid dreamers, people who are lucid most nights without trying, some of whom wake up drained after intense dreams and asked the forum how to make them stop.

Can lucid dreaming cause sleep paralysis?#

Lucid dreaming doesn't give you a new condition, but the two do travel together. In most of the studies a 2023 review could find on both, people who had more lucid dreams also had more sleep paralysis.[5] They're close cousins, since in both your mind wakes up during REM sleep while your body stays switched off (the switch that stops you acting out your dreams). In a lucid dream you're still inside the dream, and in sleep paralysis you're back in your bedroom, aware and unable to move.

The techniques people use to induce lucid dreams make that overlap more likely. Going back to sleep after a night-time alarm puts you straight into the REM-heavy end of the night. And wake-initiated methods ask you to keep your mind awake while your body falls asleep, which is exactly the moment the paralysis sets in. Plenty of us meet sleep paralysis without ever trying to lucid dream, about 8% of the general population at least once in their life, and far more among students.[6] It's frightening the first time, sometimes with a figure in the room or a weight on your chest, but it's harmless and it passes within minutes. If it happens, how to stop sleep paralysis has the steps, and the sleep paralysis demon explains the figure people see.

Is lucid dreaming bad for your sleep?#

The dream doesn't seem to hurt your sleep, but the alarm clock can. One of the most widely used methods, MILD, works better if you wake up in the night, stay up for somewhere between 30 minutes and two hours, and then go back to bed with the intention of noticing your next dream. That middle part is called Wake Back to Bed, and you'll find it next to MILD among the most popular lucid dream induction techniques. But it also breaks your night in two and shortens it, and doing that several times a week adds up to real sleep loss.

Gadgets and supplements, the two other routes people take, carry their own risks. Masks and apps that flash lights or play sounds during REM can wake you as easily as they make you lucid. Supplements sold to induce lucid dreams, galantamine above all, change the brain chemistry that runs your sleep, and sleep researchers have warned that this can mean more broken sleep, more time awake and more sleep paralysis. Neither is something to try without a doctor.

Wake Back to Bed works, but it costs you sleep, so save it for a night before a morning you can sleep in.

None of this makes the occasional Saturday experiment a problem. One short night before a lie-in costs you very little. And the same alarm on every work night of the month is a different trade, because one lie-in doesn't pay back a month of short nights. If you want to try it tonight anyway, the guide to having a lucid dream tonight sets it up with the least sleep lost.

Who should not lucid dream?#

For most of us the honest answer is nobody, as long as we keep sleeping enough. But there are exceptions, and they come from what the techniques ask your mind to do. Reality checks have you ask "am I dreaming?" over and over during the day, and that blurring of dreaming and waking is the point of the training. For someone whose grip on what's real is already shaky, it's a strange thing to practise.

The clearest evidence of a real risk comes from research on people with psychosis. In one study, 45 patients with psychotic symptoms (from schizophrenia or bipolar disorder) were compared with 28 people without them. The patients who had lucid dreams were much more likely to control them (67% and 73% of them, against 23% of the healthy lucid dreamers), and being lucid didn't make their symptoms any milder. The researchers concluded that in this group, practising lucid dreaming could strengthen delusions and hallucinations, making things that happen inside the mind feel even more like the outside world.[7]

A second study followed 187 students over two months and found the same split between the dream and the effort. How often they had lucid dreams had nothing to do with mental health symptoms, but how often they used techniques to induce them went with more symptoms and more sleep problems. By the end, the students who had been working at it showed a rise in dissociation and in schizotypy, a tendency towards odd beliefs and perceptions.[8] It's a small study, and the rise was measured in students, not patients. And it points the same way as the psychosis research, which puts the risk in the effort, and in who is making it.

So if you live with psychosis, schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, or with dissociation (moments where you feel unreal, or the world does), talk to your doctor before you try. The same goes if you're managing insomnia, since the techniques that wake you up at night undo the work of fixing it. The longer piece on lucid dreaming and mental health covers the other side, including how lucid dreaming is used against nightmares.

How to lucid dream safely#

Everything above comes down to protecting your sleep and stopping when it stops being fun. Here are the habits that keep lucid dreaming on the safe side:

  • Sleep at least seven hours, whatever technique you use.
  • Start with the methods that don't wake you up, like a dream journal, reality checks during the day and an intention set as you fall asleep.
  • Keep Wake Back to Bed for nights before a morning without an alarm.
  • Skip supplements and sleep gadgets unless a doctor has said yes.
  • Take a week off if you wake up tired, or if waking life starts to feel dreamlike.
If a technique leaves you short of seven hours of sleep, drop it for a week, because no lucid dream is worth a month of tired mornings.

A lucid dreaming app like Oniri is built around that gentler kind of training, with reality-check reminders during the day and a journal that takes your dream by voice the moment you wake. And if you're just starting, mistakes to avoid while lucid dreaming lists the ones beginners hit most.

The cheapest way to try it tonight costs you nothing, not even sleep. Ask yourself once or twice today if you might be dreaming, and really look around before you answer. Tell yourself as you fall asleep that you'll notice the next time you are, then sleep straight through to your alarm. If it works, you'll know in the morning, and if it doesn't, you've still had a full night's sleep.

자주 묻는 질문

Can you die in a lucid dream?

No. Nothing that happens in a lucid dream can hurt your body, and dying in a dream doesn't stop your heart. A lucid dream is ordinary REM sleep with part of your waking mind switched back on, and REM ends on its own several times a night. Plenty of people dream that they die and wake up perfectly fine, and the old idea that dying in a dream kills you in real life has nothing behind it.

Is it unhealthy to lucid dream every night?

Not in itself. In a survey of 489 people, mostly lucid dreamers, those who had lucid dreams more often didn't sleep worse and reported better mental well-being. What matters is how you get there. If lucid dreams come on their own and you wake up rested, nightly is fine. If you force them every night with alarms and Wake Back to Bed, you're cutting your sleep, and that's the part to stop.

Is lucid dreaming dangerous for kids and teens?

No more than it is for adults, with one difference. Teenagers need more sleep than adults, eight to ten hours a night, so techniques that wake you up in the night cost them more. Reality checks and a dream journal are fine at any age. If a child is scared by vivid dreams or sleep paralysis, or a teenager who is struggling with their mental health wants to try, talk to a doctor first.

What should you never do in a lucid dream?

There's nothing you must never do inside a lucid dream, because nothing in it can hurt you. Some things, like staring into a dream mirror, can make the dream strange or frightening, which is unpleasant but harmless. The real rules are outside the dream. Don't cut your sleep night after night to get there, don't take supplements to induce lucid dreams without asking a doctor, and remember that you can end a bad lucid dream by waking yourself up.

Is lucid dreaming bad for your brain?

There's no evidence that it is. During a lucid dream, areas at the front of the brain that usually go quiet in REM sleep switch back on, which is how you know you're dreaming. That's a normal brain in an unusual state, not damage. Researchers have raised one open question, whether swapping a lot of ordinary REM sleep for lucid REM could change what REM does for memory and emotions, and nobody has answered it yet.

자각
기법
리얼리티 체크
자각몽에서 가장 많이 쓰이는 기법
오디오 신호
밤새 소리를 들려주어 자각몽을 유도해요
Wake Back to Bed
밤중에 깼다가 다시 자각몽으로 스르르 빠져드세요
잠에 드는 동안
각성 유도 (WILD)
연상 유도 (MILD)
감각 유도 (SSILD)
손가락 유도 (FILD)
앵커 기법
숫자 세기 기법

아티클

자각몽이란 무엇이고, 왜 그렇게 멋진가
자각몽의 과학: 지금까지의 연구
자각몽이 정신 건강에 도움이 될까요?

자각몽에 도전해요, 오늘 밤.

경험이 없어도 괜찮아요.

★ 4.6 · 7,075 개 평점

출처 및 참고 문헌

이 글은 공개된 연구와 동료 심사를 거친 논문, 믿을 만한 책을 바탕으로 썼어요. 더 깊이 알고 싶다면 아래 자료를 살펴보세요.

Jean-Baptiste Beau

글쓴이

Jean-Baptiste Beau

Founder of Oniri

Jean-Baptiste founded Oniri and researches dreams, lucid dreams, creativity, and AI. He collaborates with the Sleep and Cognition Neuroimaging Laboratory in Geneva and is invested in different studies about lucid dreams and the intersection of dreams and AI, including a paper in the Journal of Sleep Research on cathartic dreams.

이 글 공유하기

더 둘러보기